Flushing culverts

About


The intent of the project is to develop designs and procedures that should be implemented in order to ensure enough water exchange in harbours usingflushing culverts embedded inside breakwaters. Flushing culverts are mostly implemented in areas where tidal ranges are low (e.g. Mediterranean Sea) and therefore provide an improvement of water exchange to an otherwise lacking tidal forced water exchange. There is currently insufficient research that would provide a description on how flushing culverts actually work as a sea water exchange instrument. Nevertheless, flushing culvert construction inside breakwaters are often considered the most cost-effective method of water exchange improvement. The purpose of the research is to outline the flushing culvert behavior using laboratory models, field measurements and numerical models. The result of the research would be engineering guidelines and simple mathematical models (e.g. equations and graphs) that would help engineers in optimal flushing culvert design. This project has been fully supported by the Croatian Science Foundation under the project number UIP-2014-09-6774.

Objectives and goals


PHASE I: Utilize a breakwater physical model with flushing culverts placed in a wave flume in order to define the wave energy transmission and water flow through the culverts due to irregular wind waves.

PHASE II: Explore the behaviour of flushing culverts under the simultaneous influence of wind waves approaching from the open sea, tidal oscillations and wind driven circulation of sea. In order to provide a complete outline of mentioned natural flow generators present in a natural setting, extensive field measurements in ACI marina Opatija have been conducted and thereafter the data analysed.

PHASE III: 3D numerical models calibrated by applying previously conducted field measurements will be used in order to define optimal vertical and horizontal positioning of the flushing culvert and their optimal geometrical design like the type of culvert cross section, number of culvert rows and columns etc.

Timeline


Phase I (2016):


Laboratory measurements were conducted in a wave flume at the Hydrotechnical Laboratory of the Faculty of Civil Engineering, University of Zagreb. Inside the wave flume with a wave generator, a breakwater physical model with embedded flushing culverts is placed. The wave generator is a "piston" type generator that can produce regular and irregular waves. The dissipation chamber is located at the opposite end of the roughly 18.5 m long and 1 m wide channel in order to minimise the wave reflection of transmitted waves on the back plate of the flume.


Experiment design

Figure 1. Laboratory experiment design


The breakwater physical model was constructed with a seaward slope of 1:1.5 and covered with boulders with an average diameter of 10 cm. Inside the breakwater, flushing culverts of various lengths and diameters were placed and tested. The culvert diameters correspond to 60 and 100 mm with three different lengths of 92 mm, 142 mm and 192 mm. Each geometrical shape of the culvert was subdued to a set of 27 wave conditions. There were 3 different water levels inside the wave flume and for each water level a set of 9 irregular waves were tested. These water levels were at the top of the culvert (W1), at the axis of the culvert (W2) and at the bottom of the culvert (W3). A total of 162 tests were conducted with spectral waves and breakwaters with one embedded flushing culvert.


Figure 2. Photo gallery of the wave flume and breakwater scale model at the University of Zagreb


Video 1. Laboratory experiments of wave energy transmission through flushing culverts


Additionally, tests with groups of 4, 6 and 8 culverts were also conducted. The four-culvert model was constructed so that all four culverts were in one row while in the six and eight-culvert models, culverts were positioned in two rows.

Phase II (2017):


Field measurements were conducted in ACI marina Opatija in northern Croatia, near the city of Rijeka (Figure 3). The marina primary rouble mound breakwater has 8 parallel 1 m diameter culverts placed at the southern part of the marina with the intention to improve water renewal inside the basin. The culverts were placed so the top of the circular culvert would correspond to the mean sea level, while the average depth inside the marina is approximately 5 m. The protected basin encompasses approximately 350 m alongshore and 150 m cross-shore, forming an area of about 40 000 m2.


Figure 3. Photo gallery taken at ACI marina Opatija during measurement device deployment/retrieval


Two measuring campaigns were conducted, one during the winter and one during the summer. The first measuring period was done between February 2nd and March 31st and the second measuring campaign was performed between July 4th and August 31st. Five Acoustic Doppler Current Profilers (ADCPs), one portable flow measurement system for pipes (PCM), one anemometer, one CTD probe and a time lapse camera were placed in ACI marina Opatija during the measuring periods.


Figure 4. Positions of measuring devices in ACI marina Opatija during winter (Feb 15 - Mar 31)


Underwater review of the measuring devices near flushing culverts were conducted after every deployment and separate CTD vertical salinity and temperature measurements were conducted at the positions of all the measuring instruments (Video 2). A sanity check of various natural influences (e.g. waves and rain) could be also performed utilizing the visual observations recorded with the time lapse camera (Video 3).


Video 2. Underwater visual inspection of deployed measuring devices near the flushing culvert


Video 3. Time-lapse video of ACI marina Opatija taken from the light tower at the head of the breakwater during the winter measuring period

Phase III (2018):

Numerical models will be utilized to investigate the flushing culvert performance in several conditions, namely: the impact of the layout of the port and the effect of horizontal positioning of the flushing culverts during varying wind and wave conditions. As a comparative parameter for determining the quality of a particular flushing culvert solution, residence time will be used. Initially, a value of 1 will be assigned to the concentration of a passive tracer inside the enclosed basin and a value of 0 outside the basin (Video 4). Due to seawater exchange, a reduction of the initial passive tracer concentration is observed. By analysing the results of each simulation carried out, corresponding "e-folding" times are obtained which represent the time required for the concentration of the passive tracer to reduce to 37% of its initial value. The residence time is actually equal to the "e-folding" time according to Kreek, 1983.


Video 4. Numerical model of pollution concentration inside ACI marina Icici


Further numerical modelling will be conducted in order to optimize the flushing culvert design in terms of cross section, number of rows and columns in a flushing culvert group, etc. It is in the best interest to maximize the flow rate through the flushing culvert and minimize the potential negative effects of overwhelming wave energy penetration. A 3D volume of fluid model will be utilized in order to assess the criteria for the flushing culvert.


Video 5. Numerical VOF simulation of wave-flushing culvert interaction

Publications


Bartolić, I. et al. (2017) ‘Impact of Wind , Tidal Variations , Wave Field and Density Gradient on the Seawater Exchange Trough Flushing Culverts in Marinas’, Acta Hydrologica Slovaca, 18(2), pp. 271–281.

Bujak, D., Carević, D. and Mostečak, H. (2017) ‘Velocities inside flushing culverts induced by waves’, Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers - Maritime Engineering, Ahead of P, pp. 1–10. doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.1680/jmaen.2017.15.

Bujak, D. et al. (2017) ‘Volumetric analysis of flow through flushing culverts embedded in breakwaters’, in 4th Coastal and Maritime Mediterranean Conference.

Bujak, D. et al. (2018) ‘Analysis of water exchange through the flushing culverts in marina Opatija’, Gradevinar, in press.

Carević, D. et al. (2017) ‘Measurements of water circulation in marina Opatija-Croatia’, in 15th International Symposium Water Management and Hydraulics Engineering.

Carević, D., Mostečak, H., Bujak, D., Lončar, G. (2018) ‘Influence of water level variations on wave transmission through flushing culverts positioned in breakwater body’, Journal of Waterway, Port, Coastal and Ocean Engineering, in press.

Lončar, G. et al. (2016) ‘The impact of culverts on the seawater exchange and wave action in marina waters’, Hrvatske Vode, 24(98).

Lončar, G. et al. (2017) ‘Analysis of the impact of winds, tide oscillations and density distribution on the sea exchange through culverts in the marinas as exemplified by the Ičići marina’, Hrvatske Vode, 25(101).